Movie Review - Mamma Mia!


Reel rating:						2/5

Reel commentary: ... rest assured that whenever the proceedings begin to veer off-track (and they will), there's always the next song just around the corner that'll surely prop things up for, at least, the next few minutes ... full review

Movie Review

By Frank Wilkins

The joy washed over us in Mamma Mia! the stage musical. Unfortunately, the movie musical version does nothing to ward off misery.

The long-awaited big screen adaptation, starring a careworn Meryl Streep, does manage to provide a few moments of joyful delight, but those come mostly from the beautiful Greek surroundings and giddy camp of the ABBA songs rather than anything derived from the film itself.

The story, loosely tied together by the hit songs of ABBA, concerns a young directionless bride-to-be, Sophie (Amanda Seyfried), who secretly invites three men (Pierce Brosnan, Colin Firth, and Stellan Skarsgard) to her upcoming wedding which is take place at mom's (Meryl Streep) run-down inn on the beautiful Greek island of Kalokairi. Sophie knows one of these men is her father, but is not sure which one. In the meantime, her frenzied mom, Donna, blows an emotional gasket once she finds out her three former boyfriends all show up at the same time. A mostly-silly string of misunderstandings and nonsensical circumstances follow that do little more than provide a visual hook to set up the next ABBA number. You know there's another one coming, but unlike on the stage, the songs in the film are dropped in at awkward moments.

Meryl Streep as Donna

All images copyright © 2008 Universal Pictures

It's amusing to watch the assembled cast – including Christine Baranski and Julie Walters as Donna's friends – sing and dance, but most of the numbers call for the performers to engage in goofy sight gags and pure slapstick silliness. While we're on the subject of singing performances, let's discuss that of Pierce Brosnan. On second thought, let's not. He's clearly a fish out of water here, his singing voice closely resembling that of… well, mine.

With the phenomenal success of the stage musical seen by more than 30 million people across the globe, it's hard to imagine the film version was adapted by the same author, Catherine Johnson. But then again, it makes sense, as this represents her freshman effort, and consequently, she's never really able to capture the same magic. What feels charming, intimate, and buoyant on stage, comes across as sloppy and careless on film. The camera picks up far more delicate details than can be seen on stage. Here, the actors overact, the camera work is terrible, and the costumes are garish and tacky.

Also struggling in this film version is first time director Phyllida Lloyd, whose work ultimately deals the death-knell to the screen version of Mamma Mia!. She's clearly not yet comfortable with framing and screening camera shots. It seems that when not sure what to do, she perches the camera high atop a craggy hillside and let's the proceedings carry on. We're left with some strange shots that, while sometimes stunningly beautiful, often feel like a crutch of inexperience. "Not sure what to do here, let's make it a long shot," was probably uttered more than once on the set.

Technical faults aside, there are still plenty of things that did work in the film, namely the songs of ABBA. Although no one ever claimed to actually listen to any of the songs when they saturated the radio waves back in the day, their catchy allure can't be denied. While the desire to dance in the aisles during the stage play (some actually did so) was missing from the film, it's actually quite remarkable how expertly the lyrics outline the plot. That's no mistake as Johnson spent countless hours poring over ABBA's complete repertoire to create a story that has universal resonance. So, rest assured that whenever the proceedings begin to veer off-track (and they will), there's always the next song just around the corner that'll surely prop things up for, at least, the next few minutes.

Frank Wilkins

Comments

Frank Says:
July 20, 2008 at 13:17

More Mamma Mia! quotes:

"There were three guys around the same time..."

"We danced on the beach, kissed on the beach and dot, dot, dot."

"Borrowed. I got it for her. Cost me ten quid and my Johnny Rotten T-shirt. See? DS: Donna Sheridan. HB: Head Banger."

"It's my last night of freedom... which is what some might see it, but for me it's the last night before the greatest adventure of my life."

Pearl Says:
August 2, 2008 at 21:39

Just saw the movie and I loved it, as did the rest of the audience. There was applause at the end and exiting the theater many were commenting on how much they enjoyed this good spirited film. Sometimes critics overlook the spirit and emotion of a film to concentrate on the technical aspects.

goth girl 2020 Says:
August 10, 2008 at 21:02

i went to see the movie i thought it would be stupid beacause i am gothic and when it was over i wannted to buy another ticket and wannted to watch it. oooooohhhhh just to let u people know who reads this i am 17

DVD Information

This title not yet on DVD

Mamma Mia! (2008)